15 Subtle Signs of a Toxic Remote Work Culture That Drives Away Your Best People

TL;DR

• Toxic remote work cultures often feature a mix of surveillance and isolation.
• The fact that we don’t trust what we can’t see creates a toxic environment.
• Subtler signs of toxic remote cultures are indicative of a larger problem.
• Peer recognition puts some company culture ownership in employee hands.

A toxic remote work culture burns everyone out, employee and leader alike. Managers have to exert double the effort to oversee every detail. Employees have to make sacrifices to look, feel, and actually be worthy of their spot. Some of the subtler signs we share today could help you get a handle on retention before it’s too late.

How does a toxic remote work culture happen?

Many toxic remote work cultures boil down to a lack of trust that comes with being unseen. Leaders feel they must surveil and micromanage to ensure remote employees are productive. Meanwhile, remote employees are statistically among the most productive–provided they aren’t subject to unhealthy management practices. Ironic!

What fully remote employees struggle with is isolation and maintaining a boundary between desk and dining room table. Being under a rather unfriendly-feeling microscope makes that even more difficult.

This dynamic puts visibility on par with quality output, and that’s not quite right either. Being seen is just one of five cultural features that drive retention:

1. High-quality recognition

2. Team rituals

3. Growth opportunities

4. Voice and visibility

5. Work-life respect

15 Signs of a toxic remote work culture

The toxic workplaces of yore were all about cliques and conflict. Today, remote work cultures have to battle persistent loneliness and unsettling feelings of being watched.

These can’t be universally observed, so we’re highlighting these specific, more telltale signs of a toxic remote work culture.

1. There was no remote work culture to speak of to begin with.

Execute the process, submit, repeat. It worked when the company first went remote, so why “fix” it? Maybe you just haven’t found the right team yet. Guess you’ll have to endure high turnover until you do.

2. Culture is spoken about, but not experienced.

Values are words shared during meetings. Company mission is a link inside an email. “This is what we’re about” feels very far away from how people interact with one another daily. Making core values part of the work experience is the base layer of a healthier culture.

3. People are always justifying their presence.

Productivity theater isn’t necessarily about covering up a lack of productivity; it’s about appearing productive to someone who is watching you. So are long explanations of what one does. These behaviors signal a lack of psychological safety in the workplace.

4. New hires lose enthusiasm in the first two months.

Cultural confusion, feeling unseen or left behind, and no emphasis on workplace connection. If someone’s participation and morale continuously decline after onboarding, the culture isn’t welcoming.

5. No one could name everyone who pitched in on the team’s last big win.

Siloed positions and “collaborations” where every hand-off is filtered through a leader only widen the divide between employees. These people do not know or speak to one another. Weekly celebrations where everyone shares a small win or engages in a team ritual are fast, easy fixes.

6. Leaders burn out from carrying culture alone.

Manager burnout on remote teams whittles communication down even further. A lack of feedback, no employee ownership of the culture, and time zones have made their efforts ineffective. Peer-driven recognition alleviates this burden.

7. A few select people are mysteriously at the center of everything.

The culture rewards extroverts alone. A third party listening in at meetings or celebrations would never know there are 20 more silent observers. Even prize drawings and other “random” occasions focus on these people.

8. People have to be tagged to comment on PRs, docs, or wins.

Got your attention yet? Remote workers with their nose to the grindstone have to be summoned by name. They don’t see the team chat or culture-related channels as worth keeping up with.

9. Celebrations are exclusive to “winners.”

Recognition is all about performance in toxic remote work cultures. To be seen, you must outdo everyone else. To be included in the celebration, you must contribute to a specific project.

10. Managers have to introduce all connections and collaborations.

Where micromanagement hurts most is when it gatekeeps employees from one another. The manager who serves as an intermediary and middleman for every interaction ensures no one feels like they belong or are worthy of trust.

11. People gather info and get answers in DMs.

Having to keep tricks of the trade in private messages is a remote problem that leads to learning loss. It can also be a symptom of toxicity when it occurs because one is afraid to look “incompetent” in public chat.

12. Survey and 1:1 results don’t line up that well.

You should always expect anonymous feedback to be a little more critical or candid. But if 1:1s are very “smile and nod” while surveys repeatedly point to disengagement, there’s a fundamental problem at the leadership level.

13. Praise is distributed by one or two people, tops.

Top-down recognition in a remote environment is a great way to burn out people leaders, for one. This type of recognition is also less effective because it doesn’t feel as genuine or spot under-the-radar wins the way peer recognition does.

14. Recognition seems reserved for time zone overlap hours.

We want as many people as possible to feel valued, no matter where they are. However, saving it up for the most well-attended moments misses the mark. Praise should be given informally and freely, no matter who is online when.

15. Morale tanks as soon as That Person uses their PTO.

There’s one go-getter or buoyant personality who makes sure the ritual happens or gets the momentum going. What happens when they’re not there? If they’ve left for good, the culture went with them.

A healthy remote culture is built on positive, natural workplace connections.

Peer-to-peer recognition can’t stop leadership from breathing down a remote worker’s neck. But over time, it can build the sort of culture that makes micromanagement obsolete. Organic trust-building, sincere praise, and just a little (non-distracting) fun retain great workers in ways that activity trackers and performance reviews never could.

Thousands of teams use HeyTaco to keep productivity high and appreciation everywhere:

1. Lives right inside of Slack or Teams, no extra logins.

2. Sits comfortably inside workflows for effortless access.

3. Everyone can use it, no matter their role, level of visibility, or tenure.

4. Low-maintenance culture-building, no extra platform.

5. Provides real-time participation insights for more effective planning.

"We started using it during COVID as a means to stay connected, and it's now become an integral part of our team culture. It is really easy to implement and use. We use it literally every day."

• Leslie G, Vice President of Customer Success

Begin your free trial and instantly make a giant leap toward a healthy, connected remote work culture.